The other documentaries
December 29, 2008 — jlgarrottAside from all of the actual books I have been reading I have been watching many other Civil War documentaries. I have not had the time to watch them in their entirety but it has been helpful to see the different styles employed. So far I have looked at:
Ken Burns’ Civil War
The Civil War and Artillery by the History Channel
Gettysburg by the Gettysburg Anniversary Committee
Civil War Battles by Marathon Music and Video
Civil War Life: Left for Dead
Civil War Minutes: Union Vol. 1
Overall the best documentaries on these subjects in my mind are those that combine reenactments with still photos and interviews. I found the Gettysburg one confusing as it used all reenactments and unfortunately the poor acting was distracting. The musical score was very well done, except for the choir bit which I found too melodramatic. The History Channel one was very well done and I was impressed with the amount of photos and documents they were able to include in such a short period of time. I think the Civil War Minutes is the best one I have watched so far. It is organized into short, detailed, but interesting, segments which is more in line with what I hope to accomplish.
Conveniently, my two sisters are in sixth grade and junior year in high school which are the two years the Civil War era is taught. I asked my youngest sister for some input on some of the other documentaries that I was watching. She said that the maps in one of them were helpful and I certainly agree, I plan on trying to include some in my film as well. She also said I shouldn’t have an old boring narrator….I tried to tell her that many people see older narrators as more creditable but I also understand not wanting to be out to sleep. I have some friends that I feel have good reading voices so I may ask them to assist me. This also made me consider the fact that in all of the films I have watched so far, none of them had a female narrator. Might I be so bold as to break the trend?
Currently I am working on writing up a general narrative that I can start planning my storyboards around. I am hopeful that I can get a reenactment lined up at one of not both of the sites before I leave. Unfortunately, the holidays are a difficult time to get a hold of people.
Some time this week I plan on going out to Brentsville to reacquaint myself with the set up and possibly film some general background shots.
March 11, 2009 at 1:08 pm
I like your analysis and mannner of speaking, thank you for this interesting ticcket, it s always nice to visit this beautiful blog